
While we had access to New York City, we decided to attempt to get half price tickets at
TKTS. This is the booth in the middle of Times Square. We have done this in the past and had great luck with it. You don't get the sold out shows, like Book of Mormon, but almost anything else is fair game.
Since we were going to a matinee on Sunday afternoon, we decided to go to the alternate TKTS at South Street Seaport. This is the only location where you can purchase the matinees, a day ahead of time. That was perfect for us.
We chose the play, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. It currently stars Daniel Radcliffe (from the Harry Potter movies) and John Larroquette (Night Court, Boston Legal and The John Larroquette Show). The casting for this remake of a 50 year old Tony winner, is excellent. The two lead actors work well together, especially when they sing "their" alma mater, "Grand Old Ivy".
The set is truly minimalist. They use stacked boxes similar to the ones on the Hollywood Squares show. The way the boxes are dressed (office staff desks, mail room boxes and shipping baskets, The President's Suite, etc) show off the location of each scene. The lighting on the boxes, also gives the sets their character.

The songs toward the end: I Believe In You and the finale itself, Brotherhood of Man, leave you walking out of the show singing.
The
Al Hirshfeld Theater, though a tight fit for the audience to get in and out of, is a beautifully restored theater and worth seeing.
My only complaint was the fact that, even though we paid half price, the tickets up in the balcony were still $81 each. A lot for a 2 1/2 hour performance...but hey, this is New York!
Highly recommended, if you visit The City.